Lakes / Pennsylvania / Fish Species / Common Carp

Pennsylvania Lakes With Common Carp

32 counted Pennsylvania lakes list Common Carp in Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission records. The largest is Pymatuning Reservoir at 13,920 acres. The deepest of them is Lake Wallenpaupack at 60 ft.

#	Lake	County	Surface Area	Max Depth
1	Pymatuning Reservoir	Crawford	13,920 acres	About 25 ft
2	Lake Wallenpaupack	Pike, Wayne	5,698 acres	60 ft
3	Shenango River Lake	Mercer	3,559 acres	30 ft
4	Presque Isle Bay	Erie	3,302 acres	None
5	Lake Wilhelm	Mercer	1,739 acres	About 22 ft
6	Lake Marburg (Codorus State Park)	York	1,275 acres	About 100 ft
7	Blue Marsh Reservoir	Berks	1,150 acres	52 ft
8	Conneaut Lake	Crawford	929 acres	None
9	Tamarack Lake	Crawford	562 acres	None
10	Loyalhanna Lake	Westmoreland	479 acres	None
11	Crooked Creek Lake	Armstrong	350 acres	None
12	Cross Creek Lake	Washington	244 acres	None
13	Glade Dam Lake	Butler	200 acres	None
14	Lackawanna Lake (State Park)	Lackawanna	198 acres	About 30 ft
15	Wilmore Dam	Cambria	195 acres	None
16	Canoe Creek Lake (State Park)	Blair	155 acres	About 22 ft
17	Speedwell Forge Lake	Lancaster	106 acres	None
18	Lake Oneida	Butler	94 acres	None
19	Dutch Fork Lake	Washington	91 acres	None
20	Canonsburg Lake	Washington	76 acres	None
21	North Park Lake	Allegheny	75 acres	None
22	Cranberry Glade Lake	Somerset	72 acres	None
23	Bridgeport Reservoir	Westmoreland	70 acres	None
24	Hopewell Lake	Berks	68 acres	About 18 ft
25	Laurel Hill Lake	Somerset	63 acres	About 16 ft
26	Dunlap Creek Lake	Fayette	50 acres	None
27	Lake Towhee	Bucks	37 acres	None
28	Mammoth Dam	Westmoreland	27 acres	None
29	Acme Dam	Westmoreland	24 acres	None
30	Lake Rowena	Cambria	14 acres	None
31	Cummings Reservoir (aka Blue Spruce Lake)	Indiana	13 acres	None
32	Marshall Lake	Allegheny	10 acres	None

Source: Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission lake data. Verified October 28, 2026.