Lakes / New York / Otsego County

Lakes in Otsego County, New York

22 lakes counted in Otsego County - the largest is Otsego Lake at 4,046 acres.

Lakes Counted

4,046 acres

Largest - Otsego Lake

167 ft

Deepest - Otsego Lake

Otsego County, highlighted, with its largest counted lakes dotted. Outlines from Census boundary data.

All Counted Lakes

#	Lake	County	Surface Area	Max Depth
1	Otsego Lake	Otsego	4,046 acres	167 ft
2	Canadarago Lake	Otsego	1,944 acres	44 ft
3	Goodyear Lake	Otsego	366 acres	30 ft
4	Wilber Lake	Otsego	89 acres	40 ft
5	Arnold Lake	Otsego	64 acres	60 ft
6	Summit Lake	Otsego	64 acres	-
7	The Fly	Otsego	63 acres	-
8	Crumhorn Lake	Otsego	62 acres	-
9	Allen Lake	Otsego	56 acres	-
10	Bear Swamp Pond	Otsego	47 acres	-
11	Bear Swamp Ponds	Otsego	44 acres	-
12	Gilbert Lake	Otsego	41 acres	20 ft
13	Moe Pond	Otsego	39 acres	-
14	Goey Pond	Otsego	36 acres	-
15	Summit Lake	Otsego	35 acres	-
16	Silver Lake	Otsego	35 acres	-
17	Crystal Lake	Otsego	33 acres	-
18	Seward Lake	Otsego	33 acres	-
19	Cranberry Bog	Otsego	32 acres	-
20	Belvedere Lake	Otsego	29 acres	-
21	Hudson Lake	Otsego	29 acres	-
22	Allen Pond	Otsego	26 acres	-

Sources: New York State DEC lake data; USGS. Verified October 30, 2026.