Lakes / New York / Madison County

Lakes in Madison County, New York

19 lakes counted in Madison County - the largest is Cazenovia Lake at 1,164 acres.

Lakes Counted

1,164 acres

Largest - Cazenovia Lake

55 ft

Deepest - DeRuyter Reservoir

Madison County, highlighted, with its largest counted lakes dotted. Outlines from Census boundary data.

All Counted Lakes

#	Lake	County	Surface Area	Max Depth
1	Cazenovia Lake	Madison	1,164 acres	45 ft
2	DeRuyter Reservoir	Madison	557 acres	55 ft
3	Tuscarora Lake	Madison	308 acres	40 ft
4	Eaton Reservoir	Madison	260 acres	-
5	Lake Moraine	Madison	188 acres	-
6	Bradley Brook Reservoir	Madison	143 acres	-
7	Hatch Lake	Madison	139 acres	-
8	Woodman Pond	Madison	115 acres	-
9	Miller Lake	Madison	100 acres	-
10	Lebanon Reservoir	Madison	96 acres	45 ft
11	Madison Reservoir	Madison	69 acres	-
12	Leland Pond	Madison	68 acres	-
13	Leland Pond	Madison	58 acres	-
14	Poolville Pond	Madison	42 acres	-
15	Torpy Pond	Madison	40 acres	-
16	Madison Lake	Madison	35 acres	-
17	Woodland Pond	Madison	34 acres	-
18	Earlville Lake	Madison	30 acres	-
19	Gorton Lake	Madison	25 acres	-

Sources: New York State DEC lake data; USGS. Verified October 30, 2026.