Lakes / New York / Herkimer County

Lakes in Herkimer County, New York

108 lakes counted in Herkimer County - the largest is Stillwater Reservoir at 6,034 acres.

108

Lakes Counted

6,034 acres

Largest - Stillwater Reservoir

75 ft

Deepest - Moshier Reservoir

Herkimer County, highlighted, with its largest counted lakes dotted. Outlines from Census boundary data.

All Counted Lakes

#	Lake	County	Surface Area	Max Depth
1	Stillwater Reservoir	Herkimer	6,034 acres	32 ft
2	Hinckley Reservoir	Herkimer	2,708 acres	-
3	Fulton Chain Lakes	Herkimer	2,054 acres	-
4	Big Moose Lake	Herkimer	1,233 acres	-
5	Fulton Chain Lakes	Herkimer	1,136 acres	-
6	Woodhull Lake	Herkimer	1,088 acres	-
7	Honnedaga Lake	Herkimer	825 acres	-
8	Little Moose Lake	Herkimer	692 acres	-
9	North Lake	Herkimer	432 acres	-
10	Canachagala Lake	Herkimer	336 acres	-
11	Sand Lake	Herkimer	313 acres	-
12	Moshier Reservoir	Herkimer	280 acres	75 ft
13	Lake Rondaxe	Herkimer	248 acres	-
14	Big Otter Lake	Herkimer	246 acres	-
15	Nicks Lake	Herkimer	206 acres	17 ft
16	Rock Lake	Herkimer	200 acres	-
17	East Canada Lake	Herkimer	173 acres	-
18	Hinckley Reservoir	Herkimer	158 acres	-
19	First Lake	Herkimer	153 acres	-
20	Twitchell Lake	Herkimer	150 acres	38 ft
21	Dart Lake	Herkimer	140 acres	-
22	Gull Lake	Herkimer	134 acres	-
23	Crooked Lake	Herkimer	134 acres	-
24	Shallow Pond	Herkimer	129 acres	-
25	Negro Lake	Herkimer	124 acres	-
26	Moss Lake	Herkimer	120 acres	-
27	Second Lake	Herkimer	118 acres	-
28	Klondike Reservoir	Herkimer	113 acres	-
29	Salmon Lake	Herkimer	106 acres	-
30	Oven Lake	Herkimer	106 acres	-
31	Clear Lake	Herkimer	105 acres	-
32	Weaver Lake	Herkimer	100 acres	11 ft
33	Witchhopple Lake	Herkimer	97 acres	-
34	Falls Lake	Herkimer	92 acres	-
35	Little Safford Lake	Herkimer	92 acres	-
36	South Lake	Herkimer	91 acres	60 ft
37	Spruce Lake	Herkimer	89 acres	-
38	Lyon Lake	Herkimer	82 acres	-
39	Chub Pond	Herkimer	81 acres	-
40	Gull Lake	Herkimer	80 acres	-
41	Bear Pond	Herkimer	80 acres	-
42	Black Creek Lake	Herkimer	79 acres	-
43	Little Woodhull Lake	Herkimer	78 acres	-
44	Wolf Pond	Herkimer	77 acres	-
45	Sunshine Pond	Herkimer	75 acres	-
46	Nelson Lake	Herkimer	75 acres	-
47	Sand Lake	Herkimer	73 acres	-
48	Young Lake	Herkimer	72 acres	-
49	Little Rock Pond	Herkimer	67 acres	-
50	Dismal Pond	Herkimer	63 acres	-
51	Fourth Lake	Herkimer	63 acres	-
52	Woods Lake	Herkimer	62 acres	-
53	Willys Lake	Herkimer	61 acres	-
54	East Pond	Herkimer	59 acres	-
55	Rock Lake	Herkimer	58 acres	-
56	Silver Lake	Herkimer	57 acres	-
57	Bear Lake	Herkimer	57 acres	-
58	Independence Lake	Herkimer	56 acres	-
59	Bubb Lake	Herkimer	53 acres	-
60	Mill Creek Lake	Herkimer	53 acres	-
61	Middle Branch Lake	Herkimer	50 acres	-
62	Safford Pond	Herkimer	49 acres	-
63	Hinckley Lake	Herkimer	49 acres	-
64	Evergreen Lake	Herkimer	48 acres	-
65	Gray Lake	Herkimer	48 acres	-
66	Third Lake	Herkimer	48 acres	-
67	Beaverdam Pond	Herkimer	47 acres	-
68	Gibbs Lake	Herkimer	47 acres	-
69	Cage Lake	Herkimer	46 acres	-
70	Middle South Pond	Herkimer	46 acres	-
71	Panther Lake	Herkimer	45 acres	-
72	Horn Lake	Herkimer	45 acres	-
73	Walker Lake	Herkimer	44 acres	-
74	Middle Settlement Lake	Herkimer	43 acres	-
75	Lower South Pond	Herkimer	43 acres	-
76	Peaked Mountain Lake	Herkimer	42 acres	-
77	Grass Pond	Herkimer	41 acres	-
78	Gull Lake	Herkimer	40 acres	-
79	West Pond	Herkimer	39 acres	-
80	Hawk Pond	Herkimer	38 acres	-
81	South Pond	Herkimer	38 acres	-
82	Ilion Reservoir Number Three	Herkimer	38 acres	-
83	East Pond	Herkimer	37 acres	-
84	Hitchcock Lake	Herkimer	36 acres	-
85	Little Salmon Lake	Herkimer	34 acres	-
86	Boyer Lake	Herkimer	34 acres	-
87	West Lake	Herkimer	32 acres	-
88	Blackfoot Pond	Herkimer	32 acres	-
89	Twin Pond	Herkimer	32 acres	-
90	Tamarack Lake	Herkimer	32 acres	-
91	Pico Lake	Herkimer	31 acres	-
92	Hitchcock Pond	Herkimer	30 acres	-
93	Diana Pond	Herkimer	30 acres	-
94	Twin Ponds	Herkimer	30 acres	-
95	Green Lake	Herkimer	29 acres	-
96	Thirsty Pond	Herkimer	28 acres	-
97	Mud Lake	Herkimer	27 acres	-
98	Lake Easka	Herkimer	27 acres	-
99	Chamber Lake	Herkimer	27 acres	-
100	Baby Lake	Herkimer	27 acres	-
101	Pepperbox Pond	Herkimer	26 acres	-
102	East Pond	Herkimer	26 acres	-
103	Fifth Creek Pond	Herkimer	26 acres	-
104	Cracker Pond	Herkimer	26 acres	-
105	Granny Marsh	Herkimer	25 acres	-
106	Big Five	Herkimer	25 acres	-
107	Lower Beech Ridge Pond	Herkimer	25 acres	-
108	Swan Lake	Herkimer	24 acres	-

Sources: New York State DEC lake data; USGS. Verified October 30, 2026.