Lakes / New York / Fish Species / Tiger Muskellunge
New York Lakes With Tiger Muskellunge
9 counted New York lakes list Tiger Muskellunge in New York State DEC records. The largest is Canadarago Lake at 1,944 acres. The deepest of them is Middle Branch Reservoir at 62 ft.
| # | Lake | County | Surface Area | Max Depth |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Canadarago Lake | Otsego | 1,944 acres | 44 ft |
| 2 | Cossayuna Lake | Washington | 661 acres | 25 ft |
| 3 | Lincoln Pond | Essex | 572 acres | 23 ft |
| 4 | Middle Branch Reservoir | Putnam | 395 acres | 62 ft |
| 5 | Findley Lake | Chautauqua | 292 acres | 37 ft |
| 6 | Lake Durant | Hamilton | 289 acres | - |
| 7 | Moon Lake | Jefferson | 243 acres | 20 ft |
| 8 | Hyde Lake | Jefferson | 179 acres | 25 ft |
| 9 | Lime Lake | Cattaraugus | 159 acres | 38 ft |
Source: New York State DEC lake data. Verified October 30, 2026.