Lakes / New York / Fish Species / Pumpkinseed Sunfish

New York Lakes With Pumpkinseed Sunfish

16 counted New York lakes list Pumpkinseed Sunfish in New York State DEC records. The largest is Indian Lake at 4,255 acres. The deepest of them is Indian Lake at 80 ft.

#	Lake	County	Surface Area	Max Depth
1	Indian Lake	Hamilton	4,255 acres	80 ft
2	Onondaga Lake	Onondaga	2,944 acres	60 ft
3	Salmon River Reservoir	Oswego	2,660 acres	50 ft
4	Cazenovia Lake	Madison	1,164 acres	45 ft
5	DeRuyter Reservoir	Madison	557 acres	55 ft
6	Tuscarora Lake	Madison	308 acres	40 ft
7	Otter Lake	Cayuga	277 acres	14 ft
8	Jamesville Reservoir	Onondaga	224 acres	35 ft
9	Duck Lake	Franklin	213 acres	20 ft
10	Chenango Lake	Chenango	133 acres	30 ft
11	Labrador Pond	Onondaga, Cortland	102 acres	5 ft
12	Lebanon Reservoir	Madison	96 acres	45 ft
13	Guilford Lake	Chenango	70 acres	70 ft
14	Lake Como	Cayuga	70 acres	20 ft
15	Nathaniel Cole Park Pond	Broome	44 acres	40 ft
16	Bowman Lake	Chenango	34 acres	15 ft

Source: New York State DEC lake data. Verified October 30, 2026.