| Vega Reservoir | Mesa | 42 mi | 679 acres | - |
| Crawford Reservoir | Delta | 57 mi | 376 acres | - |
| Rifle Gap Reservoir | Garfield | 58 mi | 241 acres | - |
| Overland Reservoir | Delta | 49 mi | 238 acres | - |
| Highline Lake | Mesa | 21 mi | 151 acres | - |
| Island Lake | Mesa | 30 mi | 144 acres | - |
| Sweitzer Lake | Delta | 37 mi | 133 acres | - |
| Eggleston Lake | Mesa | 33 mi | 130 acres | - |
| Trickel Park Reservoir | Delta | 36 mi | 114 acres | - |
| Buckeye Reservoir | Montrose | 51 mi | 109 acres | - |
| Fruit Growers Reservoir | Delta | 36 mi | 104 acres | - |
| Juniata Reservoir | Mesa | 16 mi | 99 acres | - |
| Rapid Creek Reservoir Number 1 | Mesa | 18 mi | 98 acres | - |
| Cottonwood Lake Number One | Mesa | 31 mi | 96 acres | - |
| Leon Lake | Mesa | 40 mi | 93 acres | - |
| Rapid Creek Reservoir Number 2 | Mesa | 18 mi | 85 acres | - |
| Somerville-McCullah Reservoir | Mesa | 19 mi | 85 acres | - |
| Flowing Park Reservoir | Delta | 25 mi | 81 acres | - |
| Bonham Reservoir | Mesa | 35 mi | 76 acres | - |
| Atkinson Reservoir | Mesa | 36 mi | 75 acres | - |
| Deep Ward Lake | Mesa | 31 mi | 74 acres | - |
| Kennicott Slough Reservoir | Delta | 32 mi | 71 acres | - |
| Baron Lake | Mesa | 32 mi | 69 acres | - |
| Big Creek Reservoir Number 1 | Mesa | 36 mi | 64 acres | - |
| Griffith Lake | Mesa | 27 mi | 63 acres | - |
| Anderson Reservoir Number 2 | Mesa | 23 mi | 58 acres | - |
| Hallenbeck Reservoir | Mesa | 15 mi | 56 acres | - |
| Basin Reservoir Number 1 | Mesa | 28 mi | 54 acres | - |
| Hollenbeck Reservoir Number Two | Mesa | 23 mi | 52 acres | - |
| Cheney Reservoir | Mesa | 17 mi | 51 acres | - |
| Bolen Reservoir | Mesa | 18 mi | 50 acres | - |
| Anderson Reservoir Number 1 | Mesa | 23 mi | 49 acres | - |
| Grand Mesa Reservoir Number 1 | Mesa | 24 mi | 49 acres | - |
| Colby Horse Park Reservoir | Mesa | 41 mi | 48 acres | - |
| Goodenough Reservoir | Delta | 47 mi | 48 acres | - |
| Deep Slough Reservoir | Mesa | 30 mi | 45 acres | - |
| Granby Reservoir Number 12 | Mesa | 28 mi | 42 acres | - |
| Thompson Reservoir Number 3 | Mesa | 12 mi | 41 acres | - |
| Labbe Reservoir | Mesa | 38 mi | 39 acres | - |
| Anderson Reservoir | Mesa | 38 mi | 38 acres | - |
| Carson Lake | Mesa | 24 mi | 38 acres | - |
| Cottonwood Lake Number Four | Mesa | 32 mi | 38 acres | - |
| Grand Mesa Reservoir Number 8 | Mesa | 27 mi | 38 acres | - |
| Long Slough Reservoir | Mesa | 26 mi | 38 acres | - |
| Marcot Park Reservoir | Delta | 40 mi | 38 acres | - |
| Big Battlement Lake | Mesa | 27 mi | 37 acres | - |
| Deep Creek Reservoir Number 2 | Mesa | 23 mi | 37 acres | - |
| Hotel Lake | Mesa | 31 mi | 37 acres | - |
| Scales Lake Number One | Mesa | 28 mi | 36 acres | - |
| Mid Griffith Lake | Mesa | 26 mi | 34 acres | - |
| Cedar Mesa Reservoir | Delta | 38 mi | 33 acres | - |
| Monument Reservoir Number 1 | Mesa | 43 mi | 33 acres | - |
| Cottonwood Lake Number Five | Mesa | 32 mi | 32 acres | - |
| Bull Creek Reservoir Number 4 | Mesa | 28 mi | 31 acres | - |
| Carbonate Camp Reservoir Number 6 | Delta | 35 mi | 31 acres | - |
| Weir and Johnson Reservoir | Delta | 39 mi | 31 acres | - |
| Alexander Lake | Mesa | 31 mi | 30 acres | - |
| Bailey Reservoir | Delta | 43 mi | 30 acres | - |
| Bolen, Anderson, and Jacobs Reservoir Number Two | Mesa | 19 mi | 30 acres | - |
| Terror Creek Reservoir | Delta | 54 mi | 30 acres | - |